If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
If you can figure out how many wraps per diameter, width, and gauge of the inductor are required to reach your goal you just need to see how many more are required to reach the inductors curent value. That would be the amount you need to unwrap.
An ex. For simplicity lets say you need 50 wraps to make a .50mh inductor and need 55 wraps to make a .55mh inductor. That would be 5 more wraps to make the .55mh inductor. To reach .50mh you would simply subtract 5 wraps.
Hope this makes sense. I agree with Bill though. .05mh probably won't make much difference.
The DCR of a coil is proportional to the length of wire, but Le isn't, so that scenario doesn't work. In any event you'll never hear the difference within +/- 10% from spec.
I don't understand how that wouldn't work? I mean if I can figure out how many turns it takes to get my value (say .50mh) with a online calculator and then using the same calculator figure out how many more turns it would take to get the value I have (.55mh) why couldn't I just take away the amount more of turns it took to grt to the value I have? I understand how this wouldn't be the most precise method as it would be hard to accurately measure an existing inductors size and gauge but it should get you close.
Are you saying I should be using length instead of turns? I have never tried making an inductor so I don't know.
I found an equation for creating new inductors from scratch but haven’t been able to figure out how many times I should unravel the .55mH to reach .5mH. Is it even worth it? Any advice is appreciated!
I don't understand how that wouldn't work? I mean if I can figure out how many turns it takes to get my value (say .50mh) with a online calculator and then using the same calculator figure out how many more turns it would take to get the value I have (.55mh) why couldn't I just take away the amount more of turns it took to grt to the value I have? I understand how this wouldn't be the most precise method as it would be hard to accurately measure an existing inductors size and gauge but it should get you close.
Are you saying I should be using length instead of turns? I have never tried making an inductor so I don't know.
The online calculators are OK but not real world accurate. There is variability in the wire and the wrapping. Because PE specifies the dimension of the coil, we can get close to figuring out the wire length with the calculators, so you can make a estimate of the wire to remove. I don't trust wraps as the mH is not the same value with each turn.
2 turns will be about .06, and you will certainly not hear or measure the difference, I have the same choke and a sencore Z meter,
I had to make a .5 from a .8 and counted the turns.
Guess xmax's age.
My guess: 15. His grammar is passable. His trolling is good.
You could look up the weight for the two sizes and subtract the corresponding wire/weight from the larger, .55 mH coil to get to approx. the same weight as the .50 mH coil.
I did it just for fun:
The .55 mH (AC20-55) weighs .064 Kg, and the .50 mH (AC20-50) weighs .061 Kg.... that's a .03 Kg difference, and both are 20 ga. and both have 2 zip ties according to the pic, so the main difference should be the magnet wire weight.
If you have a small digital scale, you could snip off pieces and throw them on the scale until you arrive at 3 Kg.
Could be fun just to try, but I agree, it probably won't matter to anyone's ears.
Comment