MWAF score sheets

[6thplanet]

So I'm guessing pretty much everyone has their score sheets by now. Any guesses as to which number the judges were? My guess,90-Jerry,69-Vance,83-Peter

[Wolf]

Re: MWAF score sheets

So I'm guessing pretty much everyone has their score sheets by now. Any guesses as to which number the judges were? My guess,90-Jerry,69-Vance,83-Peter

Not certain, but I CAN say that <$200 was TIGHT!! considering how well the Xenoliths did in the judging....

Later,
Wolf

[jhollander]

Re: MWAF score sheets

Agreed that Jerry is 90, not sure about the others. I do get a kick out of the how different each judge hears the same speaker. I got a 4 on Sound stage/ Imaging where the other judges ranked 8 and 9.

[GTPlus]

Re: MWAF score sheets

I didn't get mine. When did everyone receive theirs?

[Thumper Tom]

Re: MWAF score sheets

I agree, I was in the 7-8 for one and 6-7 for the other two judges. I did get some good feedback, just feel bad that it is only a 3 min demo.

[Navy Guy]

Re: MWAF score sheets

It is pretty interesting to see how much the scores varied. Judge 69 scored the lowest by far on both of my designs. Judge 83 and 90 were not off by a whole lot on my two entries.

EDIT: Actually, I just checked again and it was judge 90 that scored both of my designs the lowest

[bullittstang]

Re: MWAF score sheets

Since it was my first time, I thought I was going to get more "subjective" opinion. Such as highs were to bright, harsh or the woofer wasn't clear, or muddy. Please don't take any thing as I'm not grateful, I did get good feedback, it was just less than I was expecting.
I guess i should have been more realistic in my expectations, with so many entries and only 3 minutes (agree with Tom) to listen. I loved the format, hated I missed my flight and had to miss Friday night, but appreciate PE having the event, thought their judging was great and certainly thought mine were no where near the top anyway.
But feedback is what I crave, because I have no reference point, only what I like and what sounds good to me in my terrible acoustics office set-up.
FYI, mine were #32 (SB's-brown wavy veneer bs) and #33 (RS125-dark gray paint bs), so if some of you have "thoughts", throw them out, or just PM (if you think it's too harsh for public consumption)

[jhollander]

Re: MWAF score sheets

Paul, I score both of yours the same from where I was sitting. Plus and the highs and mids and average on the bass. The T-20 sounded better than it should have. I had you above average overall. #32 had the plus finish, sapele veneer right? It would be interesting to hear where the judges ranked originality/ design.

[6thplanet]

Re: MWAF score sheets

Judge 83 was the lowest score I had. The other two gave me a pretty good review. 69 gave the highest total.

[Thumper Tom]

Re: MWAF score sheets

It would be nice to see a plot of all the scores to see where you fall in the group and how the judges ranged.

[bullittstang]

Re: MWAF score sheets

It would be nice to see a plot of all the scores to see where you fall in the group and how the judges ranged.

+1, with an "average" for that specific category. Great idea Tom.

[kenny_k]

Re: MWAF score sheets

A map of judge location could tell a lot about the scoring.

[craigk]

Re: MWAF score sheets

It would be nice to see a plot of all the scores to see where you fall in the group and how the judges ranged.

If everyone will send me the results I will run the statistics on the results. I think it would be interesting too

[Wolf]

Re: MWAF score sheets

We can just post the numbers, right? We've done it before in past years.....
Later,
Wolf

[Navy Guy]

Re: MWAF score sheets

We can just post the numbers, right? We've done it before in past years.....
Later,
Wolf

I don't see why not