
Zobel calculation for woofers in series
I have 2 woofers wired in series and would like to know if the following calculation for a zobel circuit is correct.
2x woofers in series.
Revc  3.4679 ohms x 2 = 6.9385
Le  0.3484 mH (at 1 kHz.) = .6968
Zobel
C1= 14473.61302015319 µF
R1= 8.67312 Ohms

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
Uh, that cap value is a weee bit high. Try 14uF.

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
My calculation is more like 9.3 uF for the cap.

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
I used the following calculator for the zobel. Is the reason my calc came out different due to the calculator or does it have to do with the configuration fo the drivers?

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
Originally Posted by Hackomatic
My calculation is more like 9.3 uF for the cap.
I didn't actually look too close. I just saw the size of that cap and figured it to be a rounding error. But looking at the Le of those drivers, ya, the 9.3uF is probably more correct.

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
Originally Posted by brianpowers27
I used the following calculator for the zobel. Is the reason my calc came out different due to the calculator or does it have to do with the configuration fo the drivers?
Not sure what you used . . I used this one . . .
http://diyaudioprojects.com/Technical/SpeakerZobel/

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
I calculate 18.6uf/4.34 Ohms for a single driver. For two in series, reduce C by half and double R.

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
I just realized what I missed. In order to get the 9.2 I needed to multiply the re * 1.25.
Question: Can individual resistors be added together in series to get the desired resistance? EG: 7.5 + 1.2 = 8.7
Is the same true for capacitors?

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
Resistors placed in series add, but caps should be done in parallel.

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
Originally Posted by brianpowers27
I just realized what I missed. In order to get the 9.2 I needed to multiply the re * 1.25.
Question: Can individual resistors be added together in series to get the desired resistance? EG: 7.5 + 1.2 = 8.7
Is the same true for capacitors?
A better way to arrive at Zobel values, is to use the woofers' actual impedance profiles in ANY kind of XO simulator. You can vary the resistor and cap values and "see" how and where the rising impedance gets flattened (even though Zobel component values are not "critical", i.e.  you can vary their values by a large margin and still have a considerable effect on the otherwise continually rising impedance profile).
What drivers are you using?

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
I have 2 polk audio woofers that my friend donated to me. I am working with Jeff Bagby's passive crossover designer for the first time and am not entirely sure what I am doing.
I ordered some passive crossover components to design a 3k 4th order LR filter based upon an impedance of 8.35(per the zobel). Does this seem correct?

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
Whoah! I just modeled the crossover in the PCD. The zobel values it gives for 2 woofers wired in series are dramatically different. I used the same values. re 3.45 le .345. WHich one is right?

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
Originally Posted by brianpowers27
Whoah! I just modeled the crossover in the PCD. The zobel values it gives for 2 woofers wired in series are dramatically different. I used the same values. re 3.45 le .345. WHich one is right?
For two 4 ohm woofers, wired in series (yielding 8 ohms), your Zobel should most likely use an 8 or 9 ohm resistor (no big deal), and a cap that's in the 10uF to 14uF range. As I said before, the BEST way to determine these values is to run an actual impedance sweep on your woofers and determine the Zobel component values using some crossover simulator.
Chris

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
Thank you for your answer. I do not have any impedance testing equipment. I was surprised when I used the PCD and it calculated zobel values of 1.87uf and 20ohms. I expected the calculation to produce a slight variance but that is way out of the ballpark.

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
If you don't have an impedance sweep (and resulting .zma file), I would not be surprised if the PCD got a little wonky.

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
Originally Posted by brianpowers27
Thank you for your answer. I do not have any impedance testing equipment. I was surprised when I used the PCD and it calculated zobel values of 1.87uf and 20ohms. I expected the calculation to produce a slight variance but that is way out of the ballpark.
Let's see if we can make some sense out of this. When you say that PCD calculated these values what had been entered into the program for it to work with?
PCD is pretty powerful for a spreadsheet and contains a lot of features that I think many people are unaware that it has. For example it has several other worksheets filled with textbook calculators, including more than one for Zobels. These are accessed via the buttons near the top and to the right of the charts on the main page. I am assuming that you did not use these textbook calculators, but if so, let me know.
If you instead used the button on the main page that autocalculates the Zobel values, then you need to understand that it works by analyzing the actual impedance curve of the imported zma file. If you don't have impedance data for the driver, then what did you use?
This feature doesn't use the textbook formula for a Zobel either, because I found that the textbook formula doesn't result in a very flat impedance curve  and it shouldn't either. That's one of my gripes with this formula. First, voice coil inductance is not a pure inductance, as it only approaches 60 degrees of phase rather than the 90 degrees you would have with an inductor. Second, it is constantly changing with frequency. A typical driver that has a rated Le value of .65 mH at 1kHz may have an inductance of 6 mH at 200Hz and .15 mH at 10kHz. Because of this, I developed my own proprietary formula based on curve fitting analysis that results in a much flatter impedance.....if there is an actual zma file imported.
Let me know what you have, and I will try to help.
Jeff B.

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
Originally Posted by Jeff B.
Because of this, I developed my own proprietary formula based on curve fitting analysis that results in a much flatter impedance......
I always wondered (well assumed) that you were using something a little different. Nice work.
Aside from Jeff's PCD "autozobel", I have had the best luck with this formula:
http://www.the12volt.com/caraudio/crosscalc3.asp
Again, it requires the actual impendence curve. For nominal, I enter the lowest impendence, then the freq. at which it doubles.

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
If you think you are serious about this, you can't go wrong with the Woofer Tester 3 (free shipping right now). You get the actual impendence and the actual T/S parameters (for box modeling).
http://www.partsexpress.com/pe/showd...number=390804

Re: Zobel calculation for woofers in series
Originally Posted by Hackomatic
My calculation is more like 9.3 uF for the cap.
Based on his values, that's what I get too with the textbook formulas. That's also what PCD delivers in it's Zobel Calculator.
Thread Information
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
 You may not post new threads
 You may not post replies
 You may not post attachments
 You may not edit your posts

Forum Rules

Your #1 Source for Audio, Video & Speaker Building Components
Clearance Center
Deal of the Day
New Products
View Our latest Sales Flyer Prices Effective Through 8/31/14
Order our FREE 336 Page Full Color Catalog
Speaker Component Categories
Home Audio Speakers
Professional Audio & Guitar Speakers
Car Audio Speakers
Speaker Buyouts
Measurement & Design Tools
Subwoofer Plate Amplifiers
FullRange Plate Amplifiers
Crossover Components
Cabinet Hardware & Speaker Grill Cloth
Speaker Cabinets
Subwoofer System Kits
Speaker Kits
Speaker Repair Parts
Speaker Wire
