Somebody else making a go at....

[billfitzmaurice]

Re: Somebody else making a go at....

Well Bill, it is claimed the driver is made in the USA. I do not know how many companies are still actually building in the US aside from Eminence, or at least companies that can leverage the economy of scale to provide drivers for $400/pr speakers.

For a cast frame at that price point there are no US sources. Eminence does not make a cast frame with that configuration.

[kmibb]

Re: Somebody else making a go at....

I'm impressed that he's already passed his goal. This kickstarter thing really seems to work for some ventures. Though part of me can't help but be skeptical about the whole thing.

From the browsing I've done, it looks like 1/50 funded design or technology projects actually ship products within a year of when they say they will, and half of those are failures.

Unless it's a very simple design with a small amount of buyers, the project originator usually realizes he's in over his head.

[johnnyrichards]

Re: Somebody else making a go at....

Well Bill, it is claimed the driver is made in the USA. I do not know how many companies are still actually building in the US aside from Eminence, or at least companies that can leverage the economy of scale to provide drivers for $400/pr speakers.

They will be at RMAF, so somebody can go out there and end the endless speculation.

[billfitzmaurice]

Re: Somebody else making a go at....

High end to the people!

.......certainly no low end. The guy cut a hole in a board, stuck a speaker in it, and painted grafitti on it. Zero design involved, what do think this thing sounds like?

Not what he claims, that's for sure. One can't say if the misinformation/disinformation on his site is the result of intentional advertising hype or a lack of engineering knowledge but neither explanation gives me a warm and fuzzy.

Two dollars to a donut says it is Eminence

You're out a donut, it's not Eminence. Nor is it American made; the finished speaker is, not the driver.

[johnnyrichards]

Re: Somebody else making a go at....

High end to the people!

.......certainly no low end. The guy cut a hole in a board, stuck a speaker in it, and painted grafitti on it. Zero design involved, what do think this thing sounds like?

If he had the driver built with a high Q, it probably does ok on the bass. If the whizzer cone is even halfway competently designed, the high end will almost certainly be no worse than any other whizzer cone FR out there, regardless of price. They may, or may not have a lot of design work, or zero design work - but for $400/pr they are bringing a lot to the table, not the least of which is a pair of speakers that will spark conversation.

[duanebro]

Re: Somebody else making a go at....

A "mid fifties f3" on a 13" wide OB? No xo?

[fdieck]

Re: Somebody else making a go at....

High end to the people!

.......certainly no low end. The guy cut a hole in a board, stuck a speaker in it, and painted grafitti on it. Zero design involved, what do think this thing sounds like?

[jonasz]

Re: Somebody else making a go at....

I think it's awesome he jumped all the boxes and went for dipole straight away. High end to the people! :applause:

But seriously it would be fantastic if he could get this to gather ground in these ht-times. I remember back in the seventies and eighties there were a dedicated "stereo" with big speakers in almost every home, at least here in Scandinavia. The average soundquality was for sure better back in the days compared to today with all the "microsystems" floating around...

[Paul Carmody]

Re: Somebody else making a go at....

I'm impressed that he's already passed his goal. This kickstarter thing really seems to work for some ventures. Though part of me can't help but be skeptical about the whole thing.

[czag]

Re: Somebody else making a go at....

I wonder why the driver is not flush mounted. Does it have less of a negative impact with that type of driver?

Chris

[johnnyrichards]

Re: Somebody else making a go at....

I wonder which American company is making their drivers?

Two dollars to a donut says it is Eminence.

[Mark65]

Re: Somebody else making a go at....

Looks like a GRS 8" FR but without the ribbed cone.

NVM it's the Goldwood

http://www.parts-express.com/pe/show...number=290-379

Might be the cone, but theirs has a cast aluminum frame, not stamped steel.


Mark

[[email protected]]

Re: Somebody else making a go at....

ecellent artwork. shame it dosen't use a nicer surround like some of the peerless.

[greywarden]

Re: Somebody else making a go at....

Looks like a GRS 8" FR but without the ribbed cone.

NVM it's the Goldwood

http://www.parts-express.com/pe/showdetl.cfm?Partnumber=290-379

[foxfire3]

Re: Somebody else making a go at....

I wonder which American company is making their drivers?